May 12 2008

ER Needs More Nancys

Posted In: (Not categorized)

    I am not a social worker. No training, no classes in medical school on being a social worker, and no formal training in residency. Yet probably 35% of my time working as an emergency physician is spent ACTING like a social worker. Our society has issues, to say it simply. When these issues come to a head, or when a person needs medical attention they come to the ER. Once in my ER, whatever problem they have, whether medical, personal, family, or financial, it then becomes my problem. Often what starts as a simple complaint of ‘dizziness’ in an 80 year old, quickly becomes: “80 year old female, who lives alone with 2 cats that has no family in the area, no social support, that can’t remember the last time she ate, and refused to go to a nursing home or assisted living facility in the past.” Wow, suddenly “dizziness” is a welcome complaint compared to the rest of the story. This sad but true situation happens daily in every ER in the country. So thus I start to practice social work, without a license.
    I propose that for every ER, it be mandatory to have a 24 hour social worker. Some major medical centers already have social workers in the ER, but rarely do the smaller community hospitals. Even the big medical meccas often do not have 24 hour ER coverage. Mostly there is a social work service that works 9-5 and are on call for extreme situations. They are great at what they do, but many times they are most needed when not available. Like physicians they too spend a lot of their day buried under paperwork and performing tasks better suited for clerical employees than their own talents. When called at home after hours, the kind social worker usually responds with, “There is nothing I can do until morning” or “Just admit the patient and we can work on it tomorrow. Admit I often do, a patient that has no acute medical condition, but must be admitted for 3 days to an inpatient hospital bed before they “qualify” for placement in a facility that can help take care of them long term. Another beautifully wasteful aspect of medical care spending.
    Maybe the “there is nothing we can do tonight answer clues us in that social problems are SOCIETY problems, not ER problems. And if we had more social responsibility for ourselves and our families, we would have so many situations where someone else has to take the burden.
    Still having a Nancy Pando (a Licensed Independent Clinical Social Worker) around at all times of my shift would let me spend more time on the things I know how to do...like clinical medicine.

 

Comments

Post A Comment



05/13/2008 Ryan said:

Melody's point about social programs for the elderly hits on the fact that there can be no such thing as health care reform without societal reform. Germany has a socialized medical system, but the entire country is set up in a social way. The US is not the same kind of society as Germany, thus we can't have the same system until our society as a whole changes.
In no way do I feel anyone should be damned or denied their pursuit of help. But it can not be emergency physicians responsibility to deal with these complicated issues. It is far out of the scope of my medical training and the time I have to see each patient. That would be the idea behind more social workers in the ER until our society can deal with it more effectively.


05/12/2008 Melody said:

I've followed with interest discussions of universal and/or universal-single payer health care proposals. From the conservative wing, I always encounter the argument, that the minute healthcare is FREE, doctors and medical facilities will be OVERRUN with patients. One of the most troublesome arguments I heard was echoed by your message above: oldsters, with no support, will use doctors/doctor's offices/ERs etc. (because they would be FREE) as outlets for social connectivity. Rather than damning such use, wouldn't it more productive to find appropriate social outlets/social directors that could broaden these oldsters' lives if, indeed, they could (because they were FREE) use medical professionals/staffs to fill a great void in their lives.


Ryan's Blog Archives